Accepted "SharkRift" by Punk123

Map name: SharkRift

Spoiler

Thread: https://forum.thd.vg/threads/puntato123_sharkrift.28347/

 

I need say wonderful sharks and pit, gold and resource are fine map isn't messy, just one tinny thing maybe second "enterance" to mouth between bedrock? Yes for map.

 

I like this map, and maybe a second entrance as ferre asked would be better so the shark mouth is not "useless". Im okay if the sharks are made a little closer. Yes for me!

 

@PUNK123 can you do this small fix on this map?

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 14, 2019, Original Post Date: Nov 13, 2019 ---

Okay, changes done. Did everyone are happy now? Can we accept it, or should we reject it?

 

Still yes for me, I dont see any real big problem with it

 

I have qualms with this map but I'm already outvoted so carry on

 

We should consider any doubts.

 

My biggest concern is that the double flags behind the big dirt structure in front is too strong and the most valid attack paths are ratting thru the shark mouth or siege spamming from your own dirt stronghold, not to mention if you dig out the dirt you have a disgusting wall. With a massive pit in front thats partly void

 

Now I have doubts about this map too.

 

Good point. Maybe moving the flags in front or inside the fins? Im not sure. It really is a problem if we get a giant tower on the backwall and there is no other way than ratting.

 

@Potatobird @Pineapple your thoughts, @PUNK123 your map so you fixing it.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 27, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 11, 2019 ---

Oh I forget about this, what to do?

 

I think the flags minimally need to go in front of the dirt pillar, and it might even be neat to have a gimmicky themed map where the red zone is really small and the flags are pretty much on the noses on the sharks and you have pretty much tower wars side by side (although there's argument that this is not for official servers).

 

After waffle pointed out Im also worried about the flags being behind the dirt structure. Moving them on the front of it would make the map much better.
Placing them on the nose would indeed be a tower wars and maybe not fit for officials, but I think its worth to try out as a new gimmick.
So for me, just moving the flag in the front of the dirt fin (behind the nose or on it) will make the map better to play on and a yes from me.

 

There are two dots on the upper left part of the fix Ferre, I think its a blue flag and red barrier?
And its better with the flags on front, yes from me.

 

mk

 

I think it's reasonable yes from me

 

Fine, another meme map from @PUNK123 and @Potatobird accepted.