Solve the "full server" problem

When you look in the serverlist, most (good ping/in your region) servers are empty exept one capture the flag server that is full. What if half of the players on a full server will be moved to an other public server of the same gamemode if one is avaible?
The players get chosen by the following criterias:
- Clantag: Eigher all of the same tag get moved, or none of them
- KDR: To keep ballance, the sum of the KDRs of the moved players should be nearly the same for every team.
- Ping: People with higher pings get moved more likely, that motivates them to play more on servers in their region, but does not forbit them to play on other ones

Why should new players in the game keep playing this game when they oftenly got no server to play on because they are eigher empty or totally full. And please think out of the perspective from "normal" players who can't connect to full servers.

Sorry for my bad English, but I think you understand what I mean.

 

People would hate that, I would. I'm assuming you mean migrating people at the end of a match. (if you don't, that's messed up)
The way I see it is, servers are full because servers are full. If a server empties out people tend to follow suit, they don't want to play a small game, they want a big chaotic game.
What we need is better bot's to populate servers to make it look busy ;)
Funny name for a thread in KAG's current state XD

 

That's why I mean you should choose the people to move by the ping. People from other regions may be moved to a server in their region. That would fix two problems at once.

 

I think if the playerbase was much larger (something like 100-200 on at all times) then moving players around would be fine. But as the playerbase is very small (only a few full servers at the max), then I think this should not be implemented.
What would be cool if you could have something similar to discord, where you can type channel names as #ontopic for example. Doing something similar in game could link the server, clickable, and allows the player to join that server. Could be good if people want to migrate to a new server, making the process more efficient. It could also help newer players if they knew how/where a population went if they devided to move.

 

Specially because we have not enough players here we should move people around when necessary. Noone wants to join an empty server, so just take people from servers where noone can join and put them on empty servers.

 

Because we have so little players is the reason why we shouldn't be moving them. With that logic you are pretty much saying "You aren't allowed to play with your friends because one or two other people want to join the full server."

Having full servers is on now way a bad things. Just wait for a spot to open and then you are in. What would be the best would be some kind of queue system, similar to battlefield 1.

 

That's why I said if you have the same clan tag eigher all of you or noone of you should be moved. Look at this image and tell me that this is what you want to see if you open server browser!

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 26, 2018, Original Post Date: Apr 26, 2018 ---

Maybe the server you get moved on could have copied the map of the old one that you can continue playing the game.

 

Just join an empty server and wait a few minutes, someone will join like 75% of the time.

 

I will not. I don't want to wait on empty servers and I am defently not the only one.

 

Then why complain if you aren't gonna bother with a solution.

 

I forget some people don't have time to sit around on a server for half an hour like i do ;-;

 

Correct. Here I quote my solution which I think is the best way to solve this problem:
- The map on the full server gets copied to an empty one
- Half of the players (5 of each team) get moved to this server chosen by the following rules:
-> People of the same clan tag get moved together
-> The sum of the KDRs of all players from one team that get moved minus the sum of KDRs from the players getting moved from the other team should equal zero if possible (KDRs should not differ too much to make it fair)
-> All stay in the same teams as they were before
- This can not happen while a flag is stolen or up to 30 seconds after a flag is back in base

Tell me what still speaks against this system and I tell you a solution!

 

I don't think players would like to be moved from a full server to a 5x5 match, the point on joining a full server is to play with good amount of players, not just a bit on each side, most of the players will leave and join the original server, and if you block them from going back most of them will quit because they got "kicked for no reason from a full match"
Its better to play on a full server than a 5x5 match, its more intense, more things to do, more fun.

What would happen if you join a new-split server, watch it get full, you could get moved to a new 5x5 server. Them what if people leave because half of them don't want a 5x5 match and the other half dont want a 2x2 match because everyone else left.

If the server is full you can always wait on tdm for like 5~10 ( maybe 20 on the worst case ) minutes when the match is over and join, as every time the game is over at least 2 players quit after a match. If the match starts taking too long to finish, people will leave in the mid and you can join.

This system on my opinion will provide slots for everyone to play, but on empty servers, that no one wants.

If you don't want to wait for a slot, just quit the game and do something else. Its easier than ruining the other 20 players fun.

 

I have no idea of game developement. I am just curious about getting new people stick to the game when there are no good servers avaible to play on. What picture do we show people when they have just finished the really long but necessary tutorial and can not play online now. Maybe you like to play on full servers, but I think there are more people liking to play 5v5 more. In my opinion, you should start a vote about that. Ask the people if they like to play 10v10 more than 5v5.
There must be a long-term solution for this if we want this community to grow. For a long time now, more and more bugs appered with no major changes in the game. It hast just stopped developing. I like the gameplay how it is right now, but there are major problems to be solved like this one here. So please solve it. Maybe you have a better idea than this system?